After watching Disney’s extremely popular and highly
controversial Frozen for the third
time last night, I’ve come to the conclusion that everyone- bloggers, movie
reviewers, and Facebook moms included- needs to just “cool” down, take a step
back, and examine why this movie has had so much opinionated hype swirling
around it in the first place, and whether or not the concerns are justified.
As soon as the trailers for this movie were released, the
whispering started. The feminists and
anti-feminists were the first ones to jump all over it, because even the
trailers made it clear that two strong female characters dominated the plots of
this film. Right away judgments were
flying. Many praised the
film for following in Brave’s
footsteps, proudly
picturing girls who could hold their own and do things for themselves. As the movie was released and began to
circulate, the overwhelming majority of those criticizing it decried its
pro-gay message, claiming the entire movie was a subliminal promotion of
“coming-out”, claiming
split-second appearances of a gay family in one scene, and an
overall message of homosexual toleration.
As always, the Christians also had something to say, some finding positive
themes and echoes of moralistic truths etched within the icy scenes, while
others feeling the attempt to Christianize the film is a stretch. A simple Google search of the movie will
reveal all of these and more debates encircling the film which has won over the
hearts of the general public.
In a world that is constantly promoting immoral and
questionable lifestyles, I don’t blame people for jumping all over a movie that
definitely strikes out to be a little bit different than the classic fairytale. But I think that the concerned suspicion
which has become all too necessary when examining new media releases may have
impaired the ability of many to just enjoy something for its entertainment
value, without it having to be either the Devil’s latest tool or God’s newest
revelation.
Do I think Frozen
promotes feminism or immoral homosexuality?
No, but I also don’t think it is a pillar of Christian virtue
either. While there is something to be
said for making sure one does not expose his kids to something that could
influence their mental formation or give them the wrong ideas about good and
evil, I think it is also possible to become a bit too paranoid when screening
movies. The depth and plot twists in Frozen are too complicated for the
majority of kids to understand. From
experience, I’ve seen that kids who love the movie know all the songs, love
singing them at the top of their lungs because they’re catchy- NOT because they
like the messages that might lurk behind them, think Olaf is hilarious, the
girls pretty, and the guys cool (though not nearly as handsome as Tangled’s Flynn Rider, of course…). The adults are the ones who are offended, but
if they stopped to look at their kids they would realize that as long as they
are raising them well, in a wholesome environment, teaching them about the
faith, and striving to cultivate virtue, a Disney movie with a troubled Queen
is not going to turn the daughters feminist and the boys gay. It’s a visually beautiful movie, has some
genuinely funny scenes, and I personally believe could be twisted, turned, and
sold as either the most positively Christian film to come out in a while, or
the most problematic film to become a hit.
Just like the majority of animated films these days.
The problem is not the amount of kids who are watching the
film. The problem is the amount of
adults who are spending more time analyzing every tiny detail of Disney’s
latest releases than they are on forming their kids. To be entirely honest, the majority of Disney’s
princess films could promote problematic ideas in a household where virtue has
not been taught. But as Catholics the
educating of our children in the faith is of primary importance, and thus
should already be forming the kids before they’re being exposed to any
films. The beauty of Christianity is
that, if one has been properly formed and cultivated in its virtues and
teachings, he can turn any work of art into something beautiful, can see the
truth amidst the grey areas, and appreciate it.
Am I saying that this means anything is okay, as long as
kids know the ultimate truths? No, but I
am saying that kids growing up in a strong Catholic environment can and should
be allowed to enjoy the entertainment value of a fun, lovely cartoon without
any parents feeling guilty. Parents,
don’t let this become the next Harry
Potter or Twilight. If you’re concerned, sit down with your kids
and talk to them about the movie, listen to what they have to say. If they bring up any questions that concern
you, address them. But I think you’ll
find that they’ll just giggle about Olaf’s quips, scold Prince Hans for being
so tricky, talk about how cool Elsa’s ability to create an outdoor ice-skating
rink in the middle of the summer is, and erupt into choruses of “Do You Wanna
Build a Snowman?” And you’ll be able to
come away relieved and free to just take that worry and “let it go”.